I have no problem with photoshop, it's when they make all the pictures too bright or 'smudged' that I don't like it. When the pictures are to bright or to washed out that you can't see any details in their face what's the point? May as well be a cartoon.
^
Sayaka Akimoto is the most beautiful member imo. Ever since I first saw the 2009 member photo's she stood out. She is admitable not cute in the Japanese sense but she has this innocence that girls like Yuki can't ever capture.
Back on topic (again lol) I think Sayu's PB have been quite good in the artistic sense. Especially the last one. I wish H!P PB would do more studio photo's and more photo's in the city.
Actually there was an actress who did a Photobook in NYC that was amazing where she went clubbing and hung out in the park and stuff, I'd love H!P to do a pb like that.