Re: H!P/etc Ranking Thread
Mon Dec 05, 2011 6:57 am
Well, from a technical standpoint the top 5/bottom 5 would be the easiest. The middle would be muddled and pretty much preference. Someone can only be so good before everyone sort of balances out.
Re: H!P/etc Ranking Thread
Mon Dec 05, 2011 7:54 am
Ah, yeah. I sort of figured that. The top and bottom is easier, but it does get hazy in the middle. And it's difficult to rank 32 girls. I think what I'm most interesting in seeing is probably people's top 10. Yeah. I think that's it.
Re: H!P/etc Ranking Thread
Mon Dec 05, 2011 8:00 am
1. Takahashi Ai
2. Abe Natsumi
3. Tanaka Reina
4. Goto Maki
5. Linlin
6. Kago Ai
7. Niigaki Risa
8. Kamei Eri
9. Yasuda Kei
10. Yaguchi Mari
I think. I don't know. Might be biased. But I really really tried not to be. And no I don't agree with Asuka being the best singer ever or whatever else people say. She was great for being 12 years old, which she was, but compared to the others in top 10 (for me) she was nothing that amazing.
...idk. It's not my preference ranking anyway, I'm trying here. xD
2. Abe Natsumi
3. Tanaka Reina
4. Goto Maki
5. Linlin
6. Kago Ai
7. Niigaki Risa
8. Kamei Eri
9. Yasuda Kei
10. Yaguchi Mari
I think. I don't know. Might be biased. But I really really tried not to be. And no I don't agree with Asuka being the best singer ever or whatever else people say. She was great for being 12 years old, which she was, but compared to the others in top 10 (for me) she was nothing that amazing.
...idk. It's not my preference ranking anyway, I'm trying here. xD
Re: H!P/etc Ranking Thread
Mon Dec 05, 2011 8:08 am
^
Er, I was actually looking for your top 10 in current Hello! Project, but this is cool, too. Interesting about you having Reina so high. I've actually grown to appreciate Reina's talents a lot more now that Ai has left. I've always known that she was a good singer, but I didn't really like her that much before. And now I love her. It's weird.
Er, I was actually looking for your top 10 in current Hello! Project, but this is cool, too. Interesting about you having Reina so high. I've actually grown to appreciate Reina's talents a lot more now that Ai has left. I've always known that she was a good singer, but I didn't really like her that much before. And now I love her. It's weird.
Re: H!P/etc Ranking Thread
Mon Dec 05, 2011 8:16 am
Oh. Haha.
I have had a love/hate relationship with Reina. Her voice has bothered me a lot over the years, but I've loved her about as much. :3 And especially lately that she has grown even more -- but I can't say I've ever thought she was a technically bad singer. Because... well she's really good. xD
And, well, for some reason I thought all time MM.
Current H!P would probably go something like...
1. Suzuki Airi
1. Tanaka Reina
3. Niigaki Risa
4. Tsugunaga Momoko
5. Fukuda Kanon
6. Natsuyaki Miyabi
7. Okai Chisato
8. Maeda Yuuka
9. Sugaya Risako
10. Yajima Maimi
I think. Can't really decide who's better of Reina and Airi @.@
Again, trying not to be biased here. xD Top 5 is solid though, I think. Can't see why/if anyone would really argue that.
I have had a love/hate relationship with Reina. Her voice has bothered me a lot over the years, but I've loved her about as much. :3 And especially lately that she has grown even more -- but I can't say I've ever thought she was a technically bad singer. Because... well she's really good. xD
And, well, for some reason I thought all time MM.
Current H!P would probably go something like...
1. Suzuki Airi
1. Tanaka Reina
3. Niigaki Risa
4. Tsugunaga Momoko
5. Fukuda Kanon
6. Natsuyaki Miyabi
7. Okai Chisato
8. Maeda Yuuka
9. Sugaya Risako
10. Yajima Maimi
I think. Can't really decide who's better of Reina and Airi @.@
Again, trying not to be biased here. xD Top 5 is solid though, I think. Can't see why/if anyone would really argue that.
Re: H!P/etc Ranking Thread
Mon Dec 05, 2011 8:22 am
Current:
1. Reina Tanaka
2. Airi Suzuki
3. Miyabi Natsuyaki
4. Risa Niigaki
5. Risako Sugaya
6. Mizuki Fukumura
7. Kanon Fukuda
8. Chisato Okai
9. Yuuka Maeda
10. Kanon Suzuki
I didn't include 10th Gen, haven't heard enough of them yet. When I say Zukki is underrated I really do mean it, she has the potential to be a vocal powerhouse. Reina is, of course, number one.
Berryz Kobo has the most members where they uh... lack vocal talent. 4nin S/mileage had the most vocal talent. Current S/mileage ties with C-ute for the most technically good singers. Morning Musume is all over the place, but that's to be expected for that kind of group. Sayumi Michishige is the worst singer of the current 32.
Past Members all mixed in:
1. Maki Goto
2. Linlin
3. Ai Takahashi
4. Reina Tanaka
5. Natsumi Abe
6. Eri Kamei
7. Airi Suzuki
8. Miyabi Natsuyaki
9. Risa Niigaki
10. Kei Yasuda
1. Reina Tanaka
2. Airi Suzuki
3. Miyabi Natsuyaki
4. Risa Niigaki
5. Risako Sugaya
6. Mizuki Fukumura
7. Kanon Fukuda
8. Chisato Okai
9. Yuuka Maeda
10. Kanon Suzuki
I didn't include 10th Gen, haven't heard enough of them yet. When I say Zukki is underrated I really do mean it, she has the potential to be a vocal powerhouse. Reina is, of course, number one.
Berryz Kobo has the most members where they uh... lack vocal talent. 4nin S/mileage had the most vocal talent. Current S/mileage ties with C-ute for the most technically good singers. Morning Musume is all over the place, but that's to be expected for that kind of group. Sayumi Michishige is the worst singer of the current 32.
Past Members all mixed in:
1. Maki Goto
2. Linlin
3. Ai Takahashi
4. Reina Tanaka
5. Natsumi Abe
6. Eri Kamei
7. Airi Suzuki
8. Miyabi Natsuyaki
9. Risa Niigaki
10. Kei Yasuda
Re: H!P/etc Ranking Thread
Mon Dec 05, 2011 9:47 am
Current:
- Airi
- Momoko
- Miyabi
- Reina
- Risa
- Risako
- Yuuka
- Chisato
- Yurina
- Kanon (S/mileage)
I honestly don't think anyone outsings Buono! right now. From what I've seen, Reina and especially Risa are not as reliable in live performances as Buono!, who sound great every single time.
Lol at our top 10 singers in current H!P. Let's hope the 2011 newbies can become decent singers soon.
- Airi
- Momoko
- Miyabi
- Reina
- Risa
- Risako
- Yuuka
- Chisato
- Yurina
- Kanon (S/mileage)
I honestly don't think anyone outsings Buono! right now. From what I've seen, Reina and especially Risa are not as reliable in live performances as Buono!, who sound great every single time.
Lol at our top 10 singers in current H!P. Let's hope the 2011 newbies can become decent singers soon.
Re: H!P/etc Ranking Thread
Tue Dec 13, 2011 12:27 pm
New "Rank all of H!P" game.
http://usachan-peace.jpn.org/hello/sort/sort.html
My top 5:
1位 清水 佐紀
2位 鈴木 香音
3位 須藤 茉麻
4位 徳永千奈美
5位 飯窪 春菜
Bottom 5:
28位 真野恵里菜
29位 田中れいな
30位 光井 愛佳
31位 菅谷梨沙子
32位 嗣永 桃子
Full list of all 32:
http://usachan-peace.jpn.org/hello/sort/sort.html
My top 5:
1位 清水 佐紀
2位 鈴木 香音
3位 須藤 茉麻
4位 徳永千奈美
5位 飯窪 春菜
Bottom 5:
28位 真野恵里菜
29位 田中れいな
30位 光井 愛佳
31位 菅谷梨沙子
32位 嗣永 桃子
Full list of all 32:
Spoiler: show
Re: H!P/etc Ranking Thread
Tue Dec 13, 2011 12:57 pm
I did that the other day and basically found that I really like Yurina, Airi, Meimi, Zukki... and have an inexplicable hate for Risako, Gaki, Take-chan, new-Kei...
I didn't care for it forcing everyone into a strict order though, so... I think I'll go about doing that "group by colors" thing you guys were up to awhile back...
I didn't care for it forcing everyone into a strict order though, so... I think I'll go about doing that "group by colors" thing you guys were up to awhile back...
Re: H!P/etc Ranking Thread
Tue Dec 13, 2011 1:13 pm
My top 5:
1位 Michishige Sayumi
2位 Tanaka Reina
3位 Niigaki Risa
4位 Okai Chisato
5位 Suzuki Airi
Bottom 5:
28位 Nakanishi Kana
29位 Sudou Maasa
30位 Katsuta Rina
31位 Tamura Meimi
32位 Kudou Haruka
All 32:
1位 Michishige Sayumi
2位 Tanaka Reina
3位 Niigaki Risa
4位 Okai Chisato
5位 Suzuki Airi
Bottom 5:
28位 Nakanishi Kana
29位 Sudou Maasa
30位 Katsuta Rina
31位 Tamura Meimi
32位 Kudou Haruka
All 32:
Spoiler: show